“unreasonable, unjust, and wrong”

The 2018 election campaign was different from previous election campaigns I’ve run for two reasons:

  1. Campaigning for municipal elections usually starts – or at least really ramps up – around Labour Day; and
  2. The focus of the campaign was much more on being good, honest, ethical people than it was on issues handled by municipal or regional government.

I filed my nomination papers on May 7 and, given the news that was coming out of the media on an almost daily basis, I started campaigning heavily immediately.

At the door, I was rarely asked where I stood on issues related to infrastructure, programs, or services delivered by the Region and, instead, was routinely asked what I thought about specific (now past) politicians and their actions and behaviours. Even my counterparts who were running for various cities and towns in Niagara were being asked questions about the goings-on at the Region, rather than being asked about the issues they would be dealing with if and when they won their respective elections.

One only need read past blog entries on this site or to have been following me on social media to know how vocally opposed I’ve always been to the actions and behaviour of the last term of Council. So, whilst I sincerely wish we had never been put in this position, last night’s votes on how to address what Ontario’s Ombudsman Paul Dubé calls “unreasonable, unjust, and wrong” in his report Inside Job were historic..sadly.

This motion was crafted and moved by Councillor Kevin Gibson (Wainfleet) and seconded by Councillor George Darte (St. Catharines)


The unanimous vote on the motion by Councillors Gibson and Darte


This motion was crafted and moved by myself (St. Catharines) and seconded by Councillor Diana Huson (Pelham). Accompanying that second paragraph is a lengthy list of items I asked staff and legal counsel to investigate and report back on.


The unanimous vote on the motion by myself and Councillor Huson


This motion was recommended by staff and moved by myself. The meeting minutes will show who my seconder was.


The unanimous vote on the staff-recommended motion


As frustrated as I know many citizens feel about our need to keep much of this confidential, I ask you to please understand that there are a whole host of very good reasons as to why no one on Council should be discussing these matters to any great extent and why it is imperative and appropriate that much of the discussion regarding these matters happens in closed session.

If you’re looking for all the background, here is the St. Catharines Standard’s entire list of coverage on All the Chair’s Men

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s